2007
San Diego Theatre Critics Circle
Outstanding Direction: Kristianne Kurner (Sailor's Song)
Outstanding Ensemble: Sailor's Song
Outstanding Choreography: Robin Christ & Kathy Meyer (Sailor's Song)
Outstanding Scenic Design: Nick Fouch (Sailor's Song)
Outstanding Costume Design: Jessica John (Sailor's Song)

Patte Awards for Theatre Excellence
Outstanding Direction: Kristianne Kurner (Sailor's Song)
Outstanding Ensemble: Crimes of the Heart and Three Sisters
Outstanding Scenic Design: Nick Fouch (Sailor's Song)

San Diego Union Tribune Top Ten Productions of 2007 Crimes of the Heart
San Diego Reader Best of 2007 List: Sailor's Song
San Diego Magazine Best of 2007 List: Sailor's Song
Gay and Lesbian Times Best of 2007 List: Ensemble cast:  Sailor's Song,  Crimes of the Heart and Three Sisters, Actor: Francis Gercke and Joshua Everett Johnson in True West, Actress:Amanda Sitton in Sailor's Song, Most perfect production:  Three Sisters and Crimes of the Heart, Set design: Francis Gercke for Humble Boy. 

2006
Patte Awards for Theatre Excellence:
Outstanding Performance: Francis Gercke (Nocturne)
Outstanding Performance: Jessica John (The Playboy of the Western World)

2005
San Diego Theatre Critics Circle
Outstanding Ensemble: Curse of the Starving Class
Outstanding Direction: Francis Gercke (Curse of the Starving Class)
Outstanding Feature Performance: Joshua Everett Johnson (Curse of the Starving Class)

KPBS Patte Award for Theatre Excellence
Outstanding Ensemble: Curse of the Starving Class
Outstanding Direction: Francis Gercke (Curse of the Starving Class)
Outstanding Lead Performance: Sandra Ellis-Troy (The Waverly Gallery)

The Waverly Gallery - Critic's Choice:
San Diego Reader, San Diego City Beat, Backstage West, North County Times

SignOnSanDiego / SD Union Tribune "Top Ten Productions of 2005"
Curse of the Starving Class (#4)

2004
San Diego Theatre Critics Circle
Outstanding Ensemble: A Lie of the Mind

KPBS Patte Award for Theatre Excellence
Outstanding Ensemble: A Lie of the Mind

BackstageWest Best of 2004:
A Lie of the Mind (Ensemble & Direction)

2003
San Diego Theatre Critics Circle
Outstanding Ensemble: Orphans

Backstage.com Critics' "BEST OF" Lists

Charlene Baldridge:
Best Direction: Kristianne Kurner (Orphans)
Best Performance: Francis Gercke (Proof: SD Rep)
Best Ensemble Performance: Orphans

George Weinberg-Harter:
Best Direction: Kristianne Kurner (Orphans)
Best Ensemble: Orphans

San Diego Playbill Billie Award
Outstanding Ensemble: A Midsummer Night's Dream

2002
San Diego Playbill Billie Award
Outstanding Performance by a Supporting Actress: Julianna Lorenz (Uncle Vanya)

KPBS Patte Award for Theatre Excellence
Outstanding Performance: Francis Gercke (The Only Game in Town and A Hatful of Rain)

2001
KPBS Patte Award for Theatre Excellence
Most Exciting New Theatre Company

San Diego Union Tribune
Critic's Choice: Brilliant Traces